all natural is not good

[Rabbi]

Ofcourse all natural is not good. Like seeds, cyanide, etc. Thats why our senses avoid anything that is natural but smells bad, looks bad, feels bad, makes disgusting sounds. anything like that.

Also modern inventions hijack the brain, like candy might taste good but its literally a drug made by big companies. candies are poisonous, obv everyone knows that.

but in nature there would be no candy, everything was natural and our senses were intact, so we didnt fall to anything that is unhealthy by accident.

If it tastes unnaturally good → almost always extremely bad for you
If it tastes/looks/smells naturally disgusting → you should not eat it

Modern fake foods are the only major exception to this ancient, extremely reliable guidance system.
That's why almost everything that is sold in packages is bad for you, because it was specifically engineered to override your natural disgust & pleasure signals.

[tochbebichbe]

The second definition of "natural" in Google is as follows:
"in accordance with the nature of, or circumstances surrounding, someone or something."
If you use that definition, the statement that everything natural is good is correct. Because natural, by this definition, also means "species appropriate".
For example: Eating animals is in accordance with the nature of human beings and other carnivores. It's natural and species appropriate.
Green leaves on the other hand, for a carnivore, are not in accordance with their nature and hence not natural/species appropriate for them. For herbivores green leaves are natural.
I think the big 'Tis explained this in some video that's where I got this from.

[Rabbi]

@tochbebichbe wow yeah its a great definition. yep humans are carnivores.

Same logic flips for herbivores (birds, insects): grass/leaves = natural/good for them
raw meat = unnatural/bad for them.

and ofc for humans, true carnivore, doesnt mean cooked meat, its eating raw animals.